Dear @Vithal-Shinde,

Thank you for introducing the Candlestick & P&F Bull Pull Scanner during the Manthan Pro in May24. I have been tracking results on & off on a test portfolio, and the results are very good.

I am trying to implement the same on Futures. But I have following questions which I need help with.

1. Are the scanner results of any one day valid for all future sessions till the bullish CR? Basically, for how many days do results remain valid for? Example the results that came on say, 1 July - can a trade be taken basis that scanner on 11 July if it takes that many days for CR to hit?

2. Do the scanner results get invalidated in case of a DBS instead of a Bullish CR?

3. Can we use a tighter SL in case of Futures, in case the DBS SL is not affordable? Which is based on Dsmart or value or % etc?

4. OHLC ATR>5% breadth is a check to be used for long-only strategies - so if breadth is >15%, we do not do any fresh entries in long-only strategies. But do we also increase the SL in case of trades already entered into?

5. If we run scanner on F&O stocks - and we get some results - can we go and enter the corresponding Future for the F&O Stock which gave the result?

Please do let me know.

Thank you
Siddharth

Ok, thank you

Hi, this is not working now and page is showing an Error 404 on clicking the links above.

Ok, thanks a lot!

Hi @Vithal-Shinde / @Prashant-Shah ,

Sirs, this is with reference to the OHLC ATR Breadth discussed during Manthan Pro by @Vithal-Shinde - for long only strategies.

The ATR Breadth OHLC, ATR>5% is at 7.18% while avg value is 8.26%.

1. So this essentially means that Volatility is going down right? There is also a bearish cross over below the ATR Breadth line.
2. Since ATR Breadth is >5%, would this be a wrong time for fresh entries in long-only strategies? Or should we avoid fresh long-only entries when Breadth cross 10%/ 15%?
3. What should we do to existing long-only positions if ATR breadth crosses 5% or 15%, whichever hurdle rate we use in sl. no. 2 above.

Thank you,
Siddharth

Hi @Definedge , Stock Options (liquid - This month) for Feb expiry is not showing up as a group on TP desktop. Ref screenshot attached.

Please do have a look.

Thank you,
Sid

Thank you. Have shared my number. Looking forward to hearing from you.

Hi @Definedge , Multi-leg P&F charts are not working on Stock options. Tried multiple times now. Could you please check. Thank you

Sir, trying to plot the VEDL Multi-leg chart on P&F 0.1%*3. On line chart it is appearing as attached image. But not plotting on P&F Multi-leg chart. It is just appearing as a blank screen.

Hi @Definedge , P&F Multi-leg charts are not plotting on TP Desktop app. Been facing this issue since Monday. Could you please look into it. Thank you.

Thanks a lot Sir! I will check out the video.

Hi, how to analyse ToI on a P&F chart? And what parameters to set - 0.1%/ 0.25% etc?
Is there a video explaining this?

I remember @AP explained Line ToI when he took the Online class (Options - The Long & Short of it) and @Raju-Ranjan explains Renko ToI in Markets Kya Lagta hai.
Is there a video explaining P&F ToI on Trade point?

Thank you,
Sid