Volar vs Returns %

[Bhaavin Ashar-1718526429761]

Hi Prashant sir,
while back testing MIP30 Tadka strategy on Mid Small 400 index, I observed that Returns% based ranking method is showing better results than Volar. All statistics look much better than the ones with Volar. So if you could reemphasize why you think Volar is better approach than results % based ranking that would help to understand more about the important part of the momentum engine.
Thank you.
Attached results of both.

[Sandeep Joshi-1749292706080]

hello bhaveen sir
you change any other parameter in MIP 30 ?

[prashant.shah26@gmail.com]

Feel free to go with your backtesting results — there’s no harm in that.
In my experience, Volar performed more effectively across different sample sizes and time periods.
That said, it’s very possible that certain studies may work better on specific sample sizes, timeframes, or groups of stocks.
I would be genuinely happy if you discover something even better than what I have shared in the book.