• Recent
  • Categories
  • 0 Unread 0
  • Popular
  • Tags
  • More
    • Guidelines
    • Disclaimer
  • Users
Skins
  • Light
  • Default
  • Cerulean
  • Cosmo
  • Flatly
  • Journal
  • Litera
  • Lumen
  • Lux
  • Materia
  • Minty
  • Morph
  • Pulse
  • Quartz
  • Sandstone
  • Simplex
  • Sketchy
  • Spacelab
  • United
  • Yeti
  • Zephyr
  • Dark
  • Cyborg
  • Darkly
  • Slate
  • Solar
  • Superhero
  • Vapor
Collapse
Definedge Forum Logo
B

Bhaavin Ashar

Pro User

About
Topics
9
Replies
22
Groups
1
Followers
1
Following
7

All Replies

Recent Best Controversial

    missing stocks under one group
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Dear team,
    I have observed -

    1. Many stocks are not part of any of the NSE Indices group like NSE Microcap 250 or NSE Total Market cap Eg, SGIL is not available in any NSE groups but is part of Definedge - Forgings, Deep Industries is there on NSE but not visible in any NSE group but is visible under BSE Smallcap.

    2. Some are part of IPO groups only like for eg. Aeroflex but is not there in any NSE groups.
      Many such stocks are catching momentum when the tide is favorable.

    How to include such potential multibagger stocks in momentify scanner? For one strategy we can not select multiple groups so these stocks will never get chance to be part of momentum portfolio.

    Please include all such left out stocks under ONE mother group as well so that our momentum engine can filter these out when all boxes are ticked.


  • Alpha Index - Market trend filter
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    I was trying to run MIP 12 on Alpha Index but it throws this error "Filter Not Valid", I have selected Nifty Alpha 50 index in market trend filter and relative momentum as well. Anyone can help if I am missing something?
    b6f3396b-6957-494f-8ddc-9d92423b71a9-image.png


  • VOLAR mismatch
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    @Bhaavin Ashar @Definedge Prashant sir can you please have a look at this ?


  • Momentum Investing Engine - Suggested enhancements
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    @Prathmesh Kalubarme for learning benefit, Is it possible to share the input param of above MI result?


  • Rebalance date
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Hi
    Is there any changes done to the rebalance date or something else in the momentify system compared to 10 days back? I am not getting consistent results when rerunning a same strategy.


  • Volar vs Returns %
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Hi Prashant sir,
    while back testing MIP30 Tadka strategy on Mid Small 400 index, I observed that Returns% based ranking method is showing better results than Volar. All statistics look much better than the ones with Volar. So if you could reemphasize why you think Volar is better approach than results % based ranking that would help to understand more about the important part of the momentum engine.
    Thank you.
    Attached results of both.
    MIP30 Tadka Returns%.png MIP30 Tadka Volar.png


  • Momentify server error
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    @Definedge bump


  • VOLAR mismatch
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    @Definedge As explained on call, the values mismatch when we run the scanner with momentum strategy (Momentify option ticked).


  • Stocks on Radar : IROCN - IRFC
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    @VITTHAL GAWADE how did you get this in momentify at 184 level? I see its volar is negative, can you share details of which strategy / param used ?


  • VOLAR mismatch
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Prashant sir,
    I observed difference in the Volar that is shown in Momentum Investing scanner and the one shown under Indicator value table where I have selected Volar as (C, 252, 252 ). Could you please clarify why this difference is there? I wanted to manually see which stock is selected or removed in a particular month basis volar ranking in momentify. Attached screenshots. Volar Scanner.png Volar Indicator.png


  • Momentify server error
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    I have seen this error occur twice when doing weekly rebalance backtesting. Internet connection is working fine. Kindly check. 2025-06-04 12_05_07-Zone.png


  • Need to know where did I go wrong.
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Difficult to comment on output without knowing the input param. Please post input screens as well.


  • Swing breakout pattern in candlestick chart.
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    @Definedge bump...


  • Swing breakout pattern in candlestick chart.
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    @Bhaavin Ashar @Definedge can you please help?


  • Swing breakout pattern in candlestick chart.
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    I am also trying to build this type of scanner. Can you help please?


  • Requesting to add Exit Criteria for Simulator
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Not sure if I understood completely, but EXIT is as per VOLAR, isn't it?


  • Momentify - Dow Theory
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Is it possible to check for HH HL formation to confirm change of trend after meaningful retracement near 200 EMA area for long term uptending stock and use this as a confirmation in the momentify strategies ? I could not see HH HL scanner in Rzone hence asking this. thank you.


  • Momentify summary page
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Firstly, thank you for building this entire ecosystem of momentify.

    1. current is UI perfect , the way it is presented. All inputs all visible to the user. Perfect.
    2. RZone and Momentify need to have this differentiation to let the user know what he is working with. Same UI might create confusion.
    3. Suggestion - on the summary page, please mention the name of the strategy chosen.
    4. Request you to upload sample trading strategies and the respective videos to learn about.
      Thank you.

  • Anchor Strike
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Anchor strike (top bottom) has a whole write up more deeper than Anchor column , Please do read about that pattern.


  • Anchor Strike
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    bump


  • Anchor Strike
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    Hi team,
    I read about Anchor strike (Top Bottom) pattern on Shelf. I was trying to use this on chart but can not find this under the patterns. Can you please help in this regard how to use this pattern concept on chart?

    Thanks.


  • The Gurukul site under maintenance for the last 2 days
  • B Bhaavin Ashar

    It is still down today. when it will be up?

  • 1 / 1
  • Login

  • Login or register to search.
  • Blog
  • Youtube Videos
  • Refresh
  • First post
    Last post
0
  • Recent
  • Categories
  • Unread 0
  • Popular
  • Tags
  • More
    • Guidelines
    • Disclaimer
  • Users
  • Login

  • Login or register to search.
  • Blog
  • Youtube Videos
  • Refresh